What this article covers
Headlines say Americans are carrying record debt, but Opher Ganel adjusts seven categories of U.S. consumer debt for inflation and finds that, in 2024 dollars, every one of them, and the total, is below its past peak. Two financial advisors explain why rising balances, higher interest rates and a low savings rate still deserve attention.
Key Takeaways
Adjusted for inflation, total U.S. consumer debt is below its 2009 peak
Nominal debt figures sit at or near record highs, but they compare today’s dollars with dollars worth about 70% more in 2003. In 2024 dollars, total consumer debt is 5% below its January 2009 peak, mortgage debt is 9% below the same peak, and home equity debt is 65% below its April 2009 peak.
Credit card, student loan and auto loan debt are also below their real peaks
Credit card debt is 11% below its January 2009 peak and student loan debt is 13% below its April 2020 peak. Auto loan debt comes closest, just 1% below its January 2021 peak, while so-called “other” debt is 32% below its July 2003 peak.
Higher interest rates and a low savings rate explain why debt still feels heavy
When rates rise, more of each paycheck goes to interest, which an NBER paper co-authored by Larry Summers links to the gap between gloomy consumer sentiment and strong economic data. Advisors interviewed point out that balances are rising again, that the job market will decide whether they are sustainable, and that the savings rate has fallen to 3.8%, below the 5.8% floor of its rolling 30-year average.
It’s complicated….
“Americans owe a record $1.1 trillion in credit card debt, straining budgets” announces CBS.
“Americans Are Carrying Record Household Debt into 2024” decries MarketWatch.
Anywhere you look, you see these and other sensationalist headlines, each seeming to try and outdo the others in its gloom and doom.
Why Debt Feels Heavier When Interest Rates Rise
There’s no question that debt is a real problem for American families.
This is even more true when interest rates are so much higher than they were as recently as two years ago.
This is very likely the reason for the huge disconnect between consumer sentiment on the one hand and lower inflation and continued strong employment numbers on the other. This disconnect is so sharp that economists call it “the consumer sentiment anomaly.”
That’s the case made in a paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), by former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers and co-authors, titled “The Cost of Money is Part of the Cost of Living: New Evidence on the Consumer Sentiment Anomaly.”
If you’re in debt and interest rates go up, a larger portion of your paycheck likely goes to cover your interest costs, leaving fewer dollars to cover current needs.
Is U.S. Consumer Debt Really at a Record High After Inflation?
If you look at debt levels in nominal dollars (i.e., not adjusted for inflation), almost every type of consumer debt is at, or very near to its peak, as is total consumer debt.
The thing is, that’s a misleading picture.
Can we really compare a billion dollars worth of debt today to a billion dollars of debt back in 2003, when the dollar was worth about 70% more?
To get a clearer picture, we need to adjust those debt levels to account for inflation over time.
The following seven graphs do exactly that, and the picture is surprising.
The Bottom Line: In Real Terms, Every Category of Debt Is Below Its Peak
Looking in terms of 2024 dollars, our debt levels aren’t the highest they’ve ever been. Indeed, in every category of debt, as well as in their total, things aren’t as bad now as they’ve been in the past.
- Mortgage debt is 9% lower than its Jan 2009 peak.
- Home equity debt is 65% below its Apr 2009 peak.
- Auto loan debt, while close, is still 1% below its Jan 2021 peak.
- Credit card debt is 11% below its Jan 2009 peak.
- Student loan debt is 13% below its Apr 2020 peak.
- So-called “other” debt is 32% below its Jul 2003 peak.
- Finally, and most importantly, total consumer debt is 5% below its Jan 2009 peak.
So, yes, things are bad, but in real terms, we’ve been through worse.
Having said that, as Michael Hunsberger, ChFC®, Owner of Next Mission Financial Planning, LLC, points out:
While these debt categories aren’t at their peak, they have started to rise again, a reversal from the down-to-flat trend since the Global Financial Crisis of 2007/08. The key factor in whether these levels are sustainable is the job market. If that weakens, more people could struggle to pay off their debts, especially credit cards and auto loans.
Alison Roth, Financial Advisor at AdvicePeriod, agrees, saying:
Our current debt levels aren’t at their peak, but they aren’t far from it and may be flashing warning signs for the economy. For example, rolling 30-year averages of the national personal savings rate have never dipped below 5.8% of personal disposable income. Since early 2022, figures have come in below that average, with the most recent figure at 3.8%. This doesn’t necessarily mean impending economic doom as the media seem to say, but it may be an indicator that the consumer is feeling financial stress and current levels of debt and spending may be unsustainable. This is especially so with government stimulus tapering off, relatively high interest rates, and the restart of student loan repayments.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is U.S. consumer debt at a record high?
In nominal dollars, almost every type of consumer debt, and the total, is at or near its peak. Adjusted for inflation into 2024 dollars, though, total consumer debt is 5% below its January 2009 peak, and every individual category is below its own past peak.
Why should debt levels be adjusted for inflation?
A dollar of debt today isn’t the same as a dollar of debt years ago. In 2003, the dollar was worth about 70% more than it is now, so comparing nominal totals across decades gives a misleading picture of how heavy debt really is.
Why do consumers feel worse about debt when inflation has come down?
Higher interest rates mean that if you’re in debt, a larger share of your paycheck likely goes to interest, leaving less for current needs. Research from the National Bureau of Economic Research, co-authored by former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers, points to this cost of money as a reason for the “consumer sentiment anomaly.”
Are current consumer debt levels sustainable?
One advisor interviewed says debt has started rising again after years of flat-to-falling balances, and that the job market is the key factor: if it weakens, more people could struggle with credit card and auto loan payments. Another points to a personal savings rate well below its long-run average, along with tapering government stimulus, higher interest rates and restarted student loan repayments, as signs of consumer financial stress.
Find financial advisors who specialize in helping people like you
Search Wealthtender by specialty, location and fee type, compare advisors’ approaches, and read what their clients say before you reach out.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only, and should not be considered financial advice. You should consult a financial professional before making any major financial decisions.
About the author
Contributing Writer, Wealthtender
My career has taken some unexpected turns, from earning a PhD in experimental high-energy physics, to conducting cosmic-ray research in Antarctica, to supporting NASA projects and programs, to running my own consulting business. I also run several other small businesses and help my wife run her Marriage and Family Therapy practice.
Those experiences taught me to question assumptions, think critically, and recognize that real-world decisions of any significance rarely have simple answers that apply to everyone. Today, I bring that perspective to writing about personal finance. Drawing on my analytical background, business experience, and research, I explore financial decisions, challenge conventional wisdom, and help readers understand the tradeoffs that can affect their financial well-being. To complement my own research and experience, I also weave insights from financial professionals into my articles, drawing on their expertise and real-world experience helping clients navigate financial decisions and challenges.
At medium.com/@opher-ganel, you can read more of my articles and subscribe to receive email notifications when new ones come out.