Money Management

How to Actually Use the $1000-a-Month Retirement Savings Rule

By  Opher Ganel

Disclaimer: In order to make Wealthtender free for our readers, we earn money from advertisers, including financial professionals and educators who pay to be featured on our platform. Learn more about how we make money.

9 steps for figuring out how much you need to retire, and how to get there without letting despair overwhelm you

I love simplicity.

But sometimes, even if you avoid the trap of over-simplifying things, the simple answer is far from easy.

Case in point – the 1000-a-month savings retirement rule.

If you’re not sure what that is, here’s a quick explanation, including how to tailor it to your personal situation.

Done?

Great, let’s start figuring out how to use the rule without getting overwhelmed by how much you think you’ll need to save for retirement.

Step 1: Going from Annual Salary to Estimated Amount Needed in Retirement

Let’s use a hypothetical guy, John, age 40, who makes $80,000 a year, putting him above 56% of Americans. To figure out how much income John needs to replace in retirement, we’ll use T. Rowe Price’s guideline of 75%.

As they explain, “Why 75%? Generally, living expenses do go down in retirement. Taxes will likely be reduced as well, especially payroll taxes when you stop working. And you won’t be saving for retirement any longer.

A bit of simple math – 75% of $80,000 is $60,000, so John expects to need $5000/month in retirement.

Step 2: Using the $1000-a-Month Rule to Get a Rough Estimate of Nest Egg Needed

With no clear reason to prefer higher or lower rates, John plans to draw 3.5% of his nest egg in year 1 of his retirement, and update that dollar amount each year thereafter to account for inflation. Using the table in the above-mentioned article, John calculates need a nest egg of $1,715,000 ($343,000 for each $1000/month).

Simple, but over $1.7 million?! Yikes!

Step 3: Breathe

John starts hyperventilating.

Wouldn’t you in the same situation? Saving over $1.7 million on an $80,000 salary before turning 150?

After a bit, he calms himself down and starts figuring out his options.

Step 4: Growth of Existing Investments

John started saving for retirement, but has a below average (for his age) balance of $10,000.

Assuming the market returns its historic average of 10%/year from now until John wants to be able to retire at age 65, that $10,000 will grow to about $108,000.

Not bad, but far short of $1.7 million, and that doesn’t even account for the effects of inflation. Assuming the historic average inflation of 3%/year, that $108,000 in 30 years will be worth only about $52,000 in today’s dollars.

It’s a start, but nowhere near enough.

He needs to think some more.

Step 5: Social Security

Based on the Social Security Administration’s benefits estimator, John expects $2200 in monthly retirement benefits at age 65. However, considering the expected shortfall in Social Security’s ability to pay full benefits, John uses 79% of that, based on a cnbc.com article, or $1750/month.

Using the $1000-a-month rule, this reduces the nest egg John needs by a hefty $600,000!

Instead of $1,715,000 he’ll only need $1,115,000. Considering the $52,000 he expects his existing investments to reach by then, he needs to add $1,063,000.

That’s still a lot. Can he get there?

Step 6: Regular Investing Helps

John has some time on his side.

For every dollar he invests annually, assuming the same historic average of 10%/year returns, he expects to end up with $98 in 25 years. After accounting for 3% annual inflation, that’s $61 in today’s dollars.

John does the math…

To add $1,063,000, he’d need to save $17,500 each year (updating that each year by inflation).

Can he do that? That’s a lot of money for someone earning $80,000. John considers his annual budget…

  • Taxes (federal, state, and local) $23,000 (assuming no retirement savings tax deduction)
  • Rent and utilities $19,000
  • Health insurance $6000
  • Car ownership (loan payments, insurance, gas, maintenance, etc.) $5000
  • Food and groceries $6000
  • Miscellaneous (clothes, recreation, etc.) $6000

That’s $65,000, leaving him with $15,000 a year, which is less than the $17,500.

However, investing the $17,500 in a 401(k) reduces his taxes by $5000, so he only needs $12,500 which would leave him with a $2500 annual margin.

Doable, but it makes other goals like saving to buy a house very hard. What else can he do?

Step 7: Work an Extra Couple of Years Before Retiring?

This has multiple advantages.

First, retiring at age 67 means he’d be at the Social Security full retirement age, so his monthly benefits would increase to about $2560, or just over $2000 at the 79% level he’s more comfortable with.

This reduces his nest egg needs by another $86,000, to $977,000.

Second, his existing $10,000, adjusting for inflation, should grow to about $59,000, reducing his nest egg needs by another $7000, to $970,000.

Finally, with 27 years to contribute to his 401(k) and let the investments grow, the factor of 61 grows to 72, so the amount he needs to invest each year is just under $13,500. This reduces the tax benefit to $4000, but it still helps reduce the extra strain on his budget from $12,500 down to $9500.

With this, he’d have a somewhat more comfortable $5500 left after taking care of his budget and his retirement investments. However, it’s still hard to save tens of thousands of dollars for a down payment on a home with only $5500 left over each year.

Is there anything more he can do?

Step 8: Work Part-Time for Another 3 Years

If John continues working part time for another 3 years after he turns 67, just enough to earn $2500 a month, he can make his life easier now.

If John delays claiming benefits until he turns 70, his monthly Social Security retirement benefit would increase to $3200, or just over $2500 a month based on the 79% assumption.

Using the $1000-a-month rule, this reduces his nest egg needs by another $171,500, to $798,500.

Dividing by the same factor of 72, his annual investments needed drop to just over $11,000. With a $3000 tax benefit, he’d need $8000 out of the $15,000 his budget leaves over, leaving him $7000 a year instead of $5500.

According to a recent article by the Bryn Mawr Trust, the median home price in the US is about $300,000 (with state-specific prices ranging from a low of $107,000 in West Virginia to a high of $647,000 in Hawaii). Saving up for a 20% down payment requires about $60,000 for the US median-price home. If John saves $7000 each year for this, he can pull it off in about eight and a half years.

Not ideal, but not terrible either. Plus, if he manages to score raises faster than inflation eats away at the purchasing power of his salary, and if he avoids lifestyle inflation, he can accomplish it faster.

Step 9: Spending in Retirement Gradually Decreases

According to kitces.com, research shows that retirees don’t continue spending at the same level (adjusted for inflation) throughout retirement. In fact, they seem to reduce their spending by about 1% a year.

The simplest way to see the potential impact of this is to increase the assumed draw in the first year of retirement by 1%, since that could reduce the nest egg by 1% each year, which would then reduce the amount available to draw the following year by 1%.

John realizes this means he could go back to the $1000-a-month rule table and use the line for a 4.5% draw instead of 3.5%, reducing the nest egg size needed from $343,000 per $1000 monthly to $267,000.

With this final step, the nest egg he needs to add drops to just over $621,000, which reduces how much he needs to invest each month to just over $700. Accounting for a $2000 tax deduction, the annual impact on his budget is only $6000, leaving him $9000 a year toward a down payment on a house. He can save $60,000 for that in under 7 years.

The Bottom Line

John’s example gives you a step-by-step method to figure out how to use the corrected $1000-a-month retirement savings rule to figure out how much you should invest each year for retirement.

It also helps you figure out how to make it work if your income and spending don’t quite allow you to reach the level of retirement investing you might first think you’d need.

The following table recaps the gist the steps, in case you prefer to see all the numbers in one place.

As you can see, using the above 9 steps, John reduces the amount he needs to invest for retirement each month by almost 70%!

Opher Ganel profile pic

About the Author

Opher Ganel

My career has had many unpredictable twists and turns. A MSc in theoretical physics, PhD in experimental high-energy physics, postdoc in particle detector R&D, research position in experimental cosmic-ray physics (including a couple of visits to Antarctica), a brief stint at a small engineering services company supporting NASA, followed by starting my own small consulting practice supporting NASA projects and programs. Along the way, I started other micro businesses and helped my wife start and grow her own Marriage and Family Therapy practice. Now, I use all these experiences to also offer financial strategy services to help independent professionals achieve their personal and business finance goals.

Connect with me on my own site: OpherGanel.com and/or follow my Medium publication: medium.com/financial-strategy/.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is not intended to encourage any lifestyle changes without careful consideration and consultation with a qualified professional. This article is for reference purposes only, is generic in nature, is not intended as individual advice and is not financial or legal advice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *