Insights

Remote Work Pay Cuts Are Unconscionable: Why Employers Can’t Justify Them

By 
Opher Ganel, Ph.D.
Opher Ganel is an accomplished scientist (particle physics), instrument designer, systems engineer, instrument manager, and professional writer with over 30 years of experience in cutting-edge science and technology in collider experiments, sub-orbital projects, and satellite projects.

Learn about our Editorial Policy.

Wealthtender is a trusted, independent financial directory and educational resource governed by our strict Editorial Policy, Integrity Standards, and Terms of Use. While we receive compensation from featured professionals (a natural conflict of interest), we always operate with integrity and transparency to earn your trust. Wealthtender is not a client of these providers. ➡️ Find a Local Advisor | 🎯 Find a Specialist Advisor

What this article covers

When Google told employees that working remotely could cut their pay by as much as 25%, many were advised to simply accept it. Opher Ganel argues that remote pay cuts can’t be justified by the value employees create, by employers’ costs (remote work can save Google at least $5,000 a year per employee in office costs) or by the company’s pandemic-era results. He also covers the one case where reduced pay makes sense and what affected employees can do instead.

Key Takeaways

1

Employers pay for the value you create, not for your presence or personal costs

If you create the same value remotely as you do in the office, Opher Ganel argues there is no ethical basis for cutting your pay. His test: no employer would grant a $20,000 raise because your rent rose $1,000 a month, so lower commuting costs shouldn’t justify a pay cut either.

2

Remote workers can save large employers at least $5,000 a year per employee

A back-of-the-envelope estimate using Google’s roughly 135,000 employees, an assumed $5 billion in campus costs at a 12.76% return on assets, and about $2.8 per square foot in maintenance on a 20 million square foot footprint puts the savings near $4,725 plus $415 per employee per year, before utilities and taxes. Cutting pay for workers who lower the company’s costs, the article argues, has no ethical math behind it.

3

Accepting a remote pay cut can make sense, but employees have better options

Ben Le Fort advises taking the cut over a long commute, citing commuting’s physical, mental and financial costs and the time it frees for a side hustle. Opher Ganel suggests affected employees look for an employer that pays for value created, or use the saved commute time to build a business that captures the full value of their work.

If you’re an employee of some of the largest tech companies, you may have recently faced a tough choice.

According to a Reuters report, Google recently informed employees that if they choose to work remotely, their pay could be cut significantly – some employees report cuts as high as 25%!

Other large tech players such as Facebook and Twitter also cut pay for remote employees who move to lower-cost areas.

Should You Accept a Pay Cut to Keep Working From Home?

Making of a Millionaire creator and editor Ben Le Fort just published a piece, “If You’re Asked to Take a Pay Cut to Keep Working from Home, Do it,” where he advises such employees to take the cut rather than continue long commutes to avoid them.

He cites several costs of long commutes:

  • Physical and mental toll
  • Direct financial costs
  • Opportunity cost of having to own a (second) car

He also cites opportunities you forgo by choosing to commute:

  • Tax breaks of a home office
  • Having the time available to develop a lucrative side hustle

All of these are valid reasons for accepting a pay cut rather than commuting long distance.

However, in my opinion, that’s not the right question to address.

Why Remote Pay Cuts Fail the Value Test: You’re Paid for Results, Not Presence

Let’s start with the most basic question – why do employers pay their employees?

Obviously, if all you did as an employee was drive to the office, sit in a cubicle, and warm your seat, your employer would shortly fire you.

They don’t pay for your presence or your time.

They pay for your creating significantly higher value than the cost of employing you.

If creating that value requires your physical presence (think massage therapists, acupuncturists, chiropractors, or any other hands-on service provider), remote work is simply not tenable. If you can and do create the same value remotely as you do in person, employers have no ethical leg to stand on in cutting your pay for not driving to the office.

Not convinced? Think the employer has a plausible argument that if your costs to be able to work go down, they’re justified in cutting pay to capture some or all of that saving?

Consider the following scenario.

Your landlord informs you that at lease renewal, next month, your monthly rent will increase by $1,000 (plausible given the recent spike in real estate prices). You explain to your supervisor that you need a $20,000 raise (to account for increased taxes).

If he doesn’t laugh in your face (or fire you on the spot), his most likely response will be that your pay is based on your work, not your personal costs.

If increased personal costs don’t justify increased pay, then decreased personal costs don’t justify pay cuts.

Stay connected

See more of Wealthtender when you search Google

Add us as a preferred source, and our guides to personal finance and choosing a financial advisor can appear more often in your Google results, with a “Preferred” label in AI Overviews.

How Much Do Remote Workers Save Employers? At Least $5,000 a Year Each

Remember what we started with? About how employees are paid for creating value in excess of the cost of employing them?

Value Created >> Cost of Employment

Part I addressed the “creating value” side of that formula.

In Part II, we’ll look at the cost of employment side.

As of the end of 2020, Google had over 135,000 full-time employees. To house them, Google spends billions of dollars on their campuses. I have no idea how much the company pays ongoingly for those locations, but let’s assume the total cost of their campuses was $5 billion, and that if they didn’t have to buy them, Google would make 12.76% (that’s Google’s “return on assets”) by having that money available for other assets.

Dividing by 135,000 employees, that would be about $4,725/year per employee.

Next, according to BizJournals, Google has a 20 million sqft footprint. According to an engineering consultancy, the high-end cost of office maintenance and repairs in the US is about $2.8/sqft. This means the average cost of building maintenance and repair per Google employee is another $415/year.

Finally, there’s the cost of electricity, water, sewage, taxes, etc. which I won’t even try to guesstimate.

This back-of-the-envelope calculation shows that having a significant portion of their employees work remotely would allow Google to cut their costs by at least $5,000/year per employee. Thus, having workers work remotely can actually save Google thousands of dollars per employee per year!

What’s the ethical math that justifies Google’s cutting their pay for helping the mammoth company cut its costs?

Why Cut Remote Workers’ Pay After Record Pandemic Results?

Finally, as Le Fort points out, Google’s stock price increase dramatically during the pandemic. As of this writing, it’s up 135%.

During that time, its market cap (the value of the company) increased from ~$800 million to over $1.9 trillion!

Cutting the pay for employees who, working remotely while enduring a pandemic, powered such incredible financial results is nothing short of flabbergasting!

When Cutting Remote Workers’ Pay Does Make Sense: Proximity Housing Pay

High-tech companies do at times offer employees additional pay toward their rent or mortgage if they live very close to the office.

This makes sense in that it results in employees being fresher when they get to the office, and being able to arrive quickly in case of urgent work requirements.

Employers taking away such additional compensation for remote employees makes perfect sense.

The Bottom Line: What to Do If Your Employer Cuts Your Remote Pay

We’ve seen in the above that cutting pay for remote work cannot be justified on the basis of value created, efficiency, or financial results.

Then why would employers do something like this?

Back in 1997, Scott Adams revealed (in a Dilbert cartoon) employers’ real justification for cutting employee salaries.

If you’d rather not follow that link and see for yourself, I’ll reveal it here… “Because I can.”

If you’re a remote employee affected by such cuts, you might want to continue commuting for a short time while looking for a more ethical employer who will pay you based on the value you create rather than what they can get away with.

Alternatively, you can follow Le Fort’s advice, and use the commute time you save to build a side hustle that will much more than makeup for your reduced pay. Ultimately, you can build it up to the point that you can make the leap and quit being an employee. As a business owner, you’ll capture the full value you create, without an employer cutting a large fraction off the top.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I take a pay cut to keep working from home?

It can be the right choice if you have no better options. The article cites Ben Le Fort’s case that a pay cut can be worth it to avoid a long commute’s physical, mental and financial costs and to free time for a side hustle. Opher Ganel’s view is that the better question is whether the employer is justified in cutting your pay at all.

Why do companies cut pay for remote workers?

The article finds that remote pay cuts can’t be justified by the value employees create, by employers’ costs or by financial results. Opher Ganel’s answer, borrowed from a 1997 Dilbert cartoon, is simply “Because I can.”

How much money do employers save when employees work remotely?

Using Google as an example, the article estimates savings of at least $5,000 a year per employee: about $4,725 in forgone returns on campus investments and about $415 in building maintenance and repairs. That estimate excludes electricity, water, sewage and taxes, so actual savings could be higher.

Is it ever fair for an employer to reduce pay for remote employees?

Yes, in one case. Some tech companies pay employees extra toward rent or a mortgage if they live very close to the office, so they arrive fresher and can respond quickly to urgent work. Removing that extra compensation for remote employees makes sense.

What can I do if my employer cuts my pay for working remotely?

Opher Ganel suggests two options: keep commuting for a short time while looking for a more ethical employer that pays for the value you create, or use the commute time you save to build a side hustle. Over time, that side hustle could grow into a business that lets you keep the full value you create.

Find your fit

Find financial advisors who specialize in helping people like you

Search Wealthtender by specialty, location and fee type, compare advisors’ approaches, and read what their clients say before you reach out.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only, and should not be considered financial advice. You should consult a financial professional before making any major financial decisions.

Opher Ganel, Ph.D.

About the author

Opher Ganel, Ph.D.

Contributing Writer, Wealthtender

My career has taken some unexpected turns, from earning a PhD in experimental high-energy physics, to conducting cosmic-ray research in Antarctica, to supporting NASA projects and programs, to running my own consulting business. I also run several other small businesses and help my wife run her Marriage and Family Therapy practice.

Those experiences taught me to question assumptions, think critically, and recognize that real-world decisions of any significance rarely have simple answers that apply to everyone. Today, I bring that perspective to writing about personal finance. Drawing on my analytical background, business experience, and research, I explore financial decisions, challenge conventional wisdom, and help readers understand the tradeoffs that can affect their financial well-being. To complement my own research and experience, I also weave insights from financial professionals into my articles, drawing on their expertise and real-world experience helping clients navigate financial decisions and challenges.

At medium.com/@opher-ganel, you can read more of my articles and subscribe to receive email notifications when new ones come out.

Wealthtender is a trusted, independent financial directory and educational resource governed by our strict Editorial Policy, Integrity Standards, and Terms of Use. While we receive compensation from featured professionals (a natural conflict of interest), we always operate with integrity and transparency to earn your trust. Wealthtender is not a client of these providers. ➡️ Find a Local Advisor | 🎯 Find a Specialist Advisor