Financial Planning

Find a Financial Advisor Who Specializes in Personal Indexing: Q&A Insights from the Experts

By 
Brian Thorp
Brian Thorp is the founder and CEO of Wealthtender and Editor-in-Chief. Prior to founding Wealthtender, Brian spent nearly 22 years in multiple leadership roles at Invesco. With over 25 years in the financial services industry, Brian is applying his experience and passion at Wealthtender to help more people enjoy life with less money stress.

Learn about our Editorial Policy.

Wealthtender is a trusted, independent financial directory and educational resource governed by our strict Editorial Policy, Integrity Standards, and Terms of Use. While we receive compensation from featured professionals (a natural conflict of interest), we always operate with integrity and transparency to earn your trust. Wealthtender is not a client of these providers. ➡️ Find a Local Advisor | 🎯 Find a Specialist Advisor

Is personal indexing right for you?

Get expert insights from a financial advisor who specializes in building personal index portfolios on how direct indexing works, who benefits most, what it costs, and how to transition from mutual funds and ETFs.

If you could invest for your retirement with the potential to pay lower taxes while gaining greater control over what goes into your portfolio, would you be interested?

Thanks to a combination of advances in technology and trading tools available in the marketplace, a financial advisor who specializes in building personal index portfolios may be able to save you money on taxes with lower costs than mutual funds and ETFs, plus greater flexibility to choose the stocks and bonds in your account.

While the process may sound complicated and expensive, the reality suggests otherwise when you find the right financial advisor who specializes in personalized indexing and offers their services at a fair cost.

If you’re preparing to hire a financial advisor, should you hire an advisor who can build a personal index portfolio for you? Let’s learn more about this investment approach to help you decide if hiring an advisor who specializes in personalized indexing is right for you.

Whether you’re looking to reduce taxes, customize your holdings around your values, or manage a concentrated stock position, personal indexing may offer more flexibility than a traditional fund portfolio. For example:

  • Could tax-loss harvesting at the individual stock level improve your after-tax returns?
  • Would you like to exclude certain companies or industries from your portfolio while still tracking a broad market index?

Key Takeaways

1

Personal Index Portfolios Hold Individual Stocks Instead of a Single Fund, Enabling Customization

Instead of buying an ETF, a personal index portfolio owns the underlying stocks directly. That structure lets investors personalize holdings, exclude companies, and manage taxes in ways a fund structure doesn’t allow.

2

Active Tax Management Is One of the Biggest Benefits of Personal Indexing

Owning individual stocks makes it possible to harvest losses on specific positions while staying invested in the market. This tax-loss harvesting can improve after-tax returns for investors with taxable accounts.

3

Transitioning to a Personal Index Portfolio Requires Weighing Taxes Against Portfolio Drift

Moving existing mutual funds or ETFs into a personal index portfolio can trigger capital gains. Modeling scenarios that balance realized gains against how far the portfolio drifts from its target helps investors choose the right pace for the transition.

Why Investors Work with a Personal Indexing Specialist

Personal indexing, often called direct indexing, has become more accessible as trading costs have fallen and technology has improved. But building and maintaining a portfolio of individual stocks that tracks an index while harvesting losses, honoring exclusions, and managing concentrated positions takes expertise and ongoing attention. A financial advisor who specializes in personal index portfolios can help you decide whether the approach fits your situation.

The benefits of personal indexing depend heavily on your tax situation, the size of your taxable accounts, and the investments you already own. An advisor who builds these portfolios every day can model the tradeoffs, explain the costs, and help you transition thoughtfully rather than all at once.

Should You Hire a Personal Indexing Specialist or a Local Financial Advisor?

You’ll likely find dozens of nearby financial advisors well-suited to help you reach your money goals with a personalized plan. But it may be more difficult to find a financial advisor who specializes in serving investors interested in personal indexing.

Fortunately, many financial advisors offer virtual services so you can meet online no matter where you (or they) live. This means you can choose to hire a specialist financial advisor who lives hundreds of miles away if you decide their knowledge and experience working with investors interested in personal indexing is a better fit for your unique financial planning needs.

In the Q&A below, you’ll gain insights from a financial advisor who works with investors interested in personal indexing to help them make smart decisions to enjoy life more today while preparing for the future.

Do you have questions not answered below? Use the form on this page to submit your questions, and we’ll update this article with answers from the financial professionals and educators in the Wealthtender community. You can also contact the financial advisors featured in this article directly to set up an introductory call or ask your questions by email.

Q&A: Personal Indexing Insights for Investors

In this section, you’ll gain valuable tips from a financial advisor who specializes in working with investors interested in personal indexing.

Financial Advisor Q&A  ·  Investors Interested in Personal Indexing

Todd Smurl, CFA, Financial Advisor for Investors Interested in Personal Indexing at Integrity Financial Planning

Todd Smurl, CFA

Integrity Financial Planning  ·  Houston, TX  ·  Serves clients nationwide

Independent, fee-only fiduciary advice. A portfolio and plan built around you.
Book Intro Call

We asked Houston-based financial advisor and personal indexing specialist Todd Smurl to answer four questions to help us better understand the potential benefits of personal indexing for his clients.

QWhile many people are familiar with investing in stocks, mutual funds, and ETFs, you specialize in creating and customizing "Personal Index Portfolios" for your clients. Can you explain how this type of investing works?

Our starting point is to implement client portfolios using low-cost, broadly diversified index ETFs. This works well for many investors; however, the fund structure of ETFs poses a problem for clients who could benefit from personalization. In fact, it is impossible for ETFs to personalize their holdings.

Personal Indexing is a form of indexing that allows us to “unwrap” the fund structure of an ETF and invest directly in the underlying stocks. This “unwrapping” allows for a broad range of customization choices to be implemented for clients while retaining fidelity to the spirit of indexing.

Personal Indexing is the process of tracking the performance of an index by buying a sample of individual stocks instead of an index ETF and using optimization techniques to control risk exposures. By owning individual stocks instead of an ETF, our clients get the benefit of greater control, autonomy, and tax advantages.

The individual stock portfolios we use are designed to track the performance of the stock market, typically the US large cap market. We use these stock portfolios in place of an ETF when implementing personalized portfolios to take advantage of customization capabilities for tax management, environmental, social, and faith-based screens.

QBeyond the mechanics of creating Personal Index Portfolios, can you describe the types of people who may benefit most from this style of investing?

There are three broad categories of where Personal Index Portfolios add a lot of value:

1. Tax Alpha

One is that personal indexing can produce tax alpha. A core part of our advisory service is active tax management which is the combination of tax-loss harvesting, gains harvesting, gains deferral, holding period management, tax-lot identification, charitable gifting identification, and monitoring IRS rules in the context of a client’s unique tax budget and asset allocation.

It’s a lot of work, but it pays off by improving the tax efficiency of portfolios. Many studies have shown that this process can improve after-tax returns by up to 1% per year or more on average.

2. Transitioning Portfolios

The second is transitioning portfolios — the process of building an index-like portfolio around a client’s existing holdings with embedded capital gains and then transitioning fully over multiple tax years with the benefit of active tax management.

A special case is where a client has a highly appreciated single stock, typically acquired either as an executive or through the sale of a business. Personal indexing is a great process for building an index-like portfolio around a low basis stock position and then using tax-loss harvesting techniques to efficiently offset gains as we systematically reduce the concentration. Over time this technique can diversify a concentrated holding into an index-like portfolio while retaining complete control over net realized capital gains.

3. Client Preferences

The third category is for clients who have unique personal preferences or environmental, social, or faith-based values they want to be reflected in their portfolio. Owning a Personal Index Portfolio of individual stocks allows us to manage these constraints in a tax and risk-controlled process.

It gets fun when we are able to perform a “portfolio rescue,” helping a client transition from a large broker-dealer type firm where they have multiple separately managed accounts, mutual funds, built-in gains, etc. with no clear direction or tax oversight. We can combine their assets into one account, making the paperwork as simple as possible, providing comprehensive tax management while at the same time implementing social or faith-based screens. Often this dramatically lowers their overall cost structure as well.

QHow does the cost of building and maintaining a Personal Index Portfolio for a typical client compare to an investment portfolio traditionally offered by many financial advisors?

Our baseline when constructing portfolios is to use low-cost index ETFs as building blocks. In that scenario, as of 2022, an all-ETF portfolio with a 70/30 allocation has an internal expense ratio of a little less than 5bps.

When we swap out the US large-cap ETF for an individual stock tracking portfolio the internal expense ratio of the entire portfolio goes down to about 3.5bps since the portfolio of individual stocks doesn’t have an expense ratio.

We provide Personal Index Portfolios, active tax management, environmental, social, and faith-based investing at no additional cost above our investment advisory fee.

QFor people interested in hiring you to create a Personal Index Portfolio who are already invested in mutual funds and/or ETFs, what does the transition process look like, and are there tax implications to consider?

For each new client, we analyze multiple scenarios detailing the tradeoffs between portfolio drift and realized capital gains when transitioning a clients’ existing holdings. Those scenarios represent a range of potential decisions from high capital gains and low drift to low capital gains and high drift.

The result of this scenario analysis is a written transition plan and an annual tax budget we use to manage the process within our active tax management framework. This gives the client control over annual net realized gains while understanding the risk and return tradeoffs involved.

Todd Smurl, CFA, Financial Advisor for Investors Interested in Personal Indexing at Integrity Financial Planning

Considering a financial advisor who specializes in working with Investors Interested in Personal Indexing?

Are you a financial advisor who specializes in serving investors interested in personal indexing?

Join Wealthtender and get featured as a specialist financial advisor based on your knowledge and experience (subject to availability and terms). Sign up today and join financial advisors attracting their ideal clients on Wealthtender, or request more information by email:

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Are you a financial planner or advisor interested in learning more about personal indexing?

Whether you’re an advisor interested in learning more about personal indexing, or a financial planner looking for a partner who can create and manage personal index portfolios for your clients, schedule a call with Todd Smurl who can offer insights and suggestions to help you get started.

Ask an advisor

Have Questions About Personal Indexing?

Keep exploring

Find the Right Financial Advisor for You

Browse specialists, compare advisors near you, or find advisors who know your employer’s benefits.

Brian Thorp

About the author

Brian Thorp

Founder & CEO and Editor-in-Chief, Wealthtender

Brian Thorp is the founder and CEO of Wealthtender and its Editor-in-Chief. With more than 25 years in the financial services industry, he is applying his experience and passion at Wealthtender to help more people enjoy life with less money stress.

Brian and his wife live in Austin, Texas.

Wealthtender is a trusted, independent financial directory and educational resource governed by our strict Editorial Policy, Integrity Standards, and Terms of Use. While we receive compensation from featured professionals (a natural conflict of interest), we always operate with integrity and transparency to earn your trust. Wealthtender is not a client of these providers. ➡️ Find a Local Advisor | 🎯 Find a Specialist Advisor