What this article covers
Opher Ganel learned budgeting the hard way, keeping a family of four afloat on a $31,000 salary after moving to the US. He walks through the seven budgeting mistakes he sees most often, from not budgeting or tracking spending at all to skipping an emergency fund, under-investing for retirement, being too frugal and buying on impulse, with concrete steps to fix each one. Two financial advisors add tips on counting paycheck deductions and planning for irregular expenses.
Key Takeaways
A budget is a financial plan built around your goals, not just a list of bills
Opher recommends starting with your priorities and goals, setting aside “pay yourself first” amounts for each, adding fixed costs like rent and car payments, then trimming discretionary categories that don’t align. Stephan Shipe of Scholar Financial Advising adds that budgets should start from gross income and count taxes, insurance, retirement savings, lumpy income and big irregular expenses.
Every budget needs an emergency fund and retirement investing, even a tight one
Opher sizes an emergency fund by multiplying the months you want covered by a bare-bones “emergency situation budget,” keeping 2-3 months in cash. For retirement, he reduces projected Social Security benefits by 23% and multiplies the annual shortfall by 33.3 (a 3% withdrawal rate) rather than the 4% rule’s 25.
Budget for fun and irregular expenses, and slow down impulse purchases
Extreme frugality fails like a crash diet, so Opher suggests setting aside even $50 a month ($600 a year) for things you love and waiting at least a week before unplanned purchases. Jen Swindler of Vincere Wealth Management advises totaling annual “revolving” expenses such as gifts, vet checkups and annual fees, then saving the monthly average.
Here are my top 7 ways your budgeting fails at getting you to your goals and what you can do differently to win the budgeting game.
We had just moved to the US. Both of us were 30, and we had two toddlers.
We needed to have enough money to buy a used car and some cheap furniture. To raise that money, we sold everything we owned that we couldn’t take with us. Our car, our appliances, our TV and hi-fi, and our furniture. When that didn’t bring in enough, we borrowed a few thousand dollars from my parents.
I knew my salary would be just $31,000. I also knew that my immigration status locked me into that job and that my wife’s status would prevent her from working at all.
Budgeting wasn’t a matter of choice. Keeping a family of 4 afloat on $31,000 wouldn’t be easy.
Almost obsessively, I’d review our budget over and over, trying to figure out what we could remove or at least trim. I’d try to convince myself that we could cut our grocery budget by $100 or even $50. Somehow, by the end of the month, the total spent on groceries was the same as it was before.
I tried thinking of something else we could cut. Nada. Our budget had very little fat.
Lunch was a sandwich from home, or at most, a fast-food “meal.”
Dinner was often a few $0.20 packets of supermarket ramen noodles.
When we discovered that we could get a cooked meal from the local hospital cafeteria for the same $3 as a Big Mac Meal, that was a huge deal.
We weren’t willing to make the sort of changes needed to cut our expenses significantly. Things like moving to a one-bedroom, one-bath apartment in an unsafe neighborhood.
The great “hope” was winning a prize from the Publishers Clearing House sweepstakes. The odds were vanishingly small, but better a next-to-zero-chance hope than no hope at all.
My Conclusions from this Experience:
That time was financially challenging, but it wasn’t all bad.
We had good times with friends, inviting them over to our place or going over to their places. Once a year, we’d take a road trip to visit friends a couple of states over, staying in their house to avoid hotel costs. Occasionally, our parents would visit from overseas and take us on a fun (though still modest) vacation.
These are the 5 lessons I learned from that time:
- If you make barely enough to survive, you can’t budget your way to prosperity; but if you don’t track your spending, you can easily get into financial problems (a.k.a., a debt spiral).
- No matter how little you make, carve out at least a few dollars to set aside for an emergency, at least a few dollars for the future, and at least a few dollars to have fun.
- Family support is crucial to financial survival.
- Even when you can’t afford much, you can still have a great time with friends.
- Always keep hope alive and keep your eyes open for opportunities; one of my favorite quotes says, “Good fortune is what happens when opportunity meets preparedness.”
Stay connected
See more of Wealthtender when you search Google
Add us as a preferred source, and our guides to personal finance and choosing a financial advisor can appear more often in your Google results, with a “Preferred” label in AI Overviews.
7 Common Budgeting Mistakes and How to Fix Each One
My experience also taught me that budgeting is an art as well as a science and that there are many ways you can fail at it. Here are my top 7.
Budgeting Mistake #1: Not Having a Budget at All
As the well-known quote says, “failing to plan is like planning to fail.” A budget is nothing more or less than a financial plan for the coming year(s). If you don’t budget, why would you expect to achieve anything financially?
What to do differently:
- A good budget aligns with your priorities and goals and makes them concrete. Establish your financial priorities and goals. These could include, e.g., retirement (or financial independence, if you don’t want to plan on ever not working), buying a home, buying (or replacing) a car, saving for your kids’ college education, setting up an emergency fund, etc.
- Thinking about each goal, ask yourself where you want to be in a year, 5 years, 10 years, etc.
- Figure out how much money you need to set aside for each goal, given its size and how long until you want to reach it. These amounts are the “pay yourself first” portion of your budget.
- Note how much you’re spending on things you can’t easily change (e.g., mortgage or rent, car loan payments, etc.) and add those to the budget.
- Figure out how much you’re spending on discretionary categories. Then, see how well they align with your goals and priorities.
- Finally, trim or eliminate those discretionary categories that don’t align with your priorities and add to the budget those that do.
Once you decide to budget, Stephan Shipe, Ph.D., CFA, CFP®, Owner & Lead Advisor at Scholar Financial Advising, suggests going beyond the income and expenses you see moving into and out of your accounts every month. He says, “A typical budgeting problem I see is when clients don’t include in their budget items like insurance, retirement savings, or other expenses that are deducted before their income reaches their checking account. We solve this by starting with total gross income and including taxes and other deductions as expense items. This problem is worse if you have “lumpy” income from bonuses or tax refunds, or big irregular expenses. Because these don’t show up monthly, some clients forget to include them in their budget. You need to account for these if you’re planning to retire or want a better understanding of your expenses.”
Budgeting Mistake #2: Not Tracking Where Your Money Goes
If you don’t know where your money goes, you can’t stop it from leaking and getting frittered down to nothing. Tracking lets you compare your actual spending with your budgeted priorities. That, in turn, lets you figure out what you need to change (and it might be recognizing that something you didn’t realize was a priority really is one).
What to do differently:
- Figure out what tracking method is most comfortable and efficient for you. It could be using Quicken and Excel spreadsheets like me, a smartphone app such as Mint, or old-school like putting set amounts of cash in budget-category-specific envelopes.
- Start recording how much you spend in each category.
- Periodically review your actual spending and compare it to your budget. Do this monthly, quarterly, and annually.
- Where you see yourself consistently overspending your budget, consider if this is a hidden priority that you should add to your budget or increase. If it isn’t, ask yourself why you’re wasting money on something that pushes you further away from achieving your goals. You may need to break bad habits or create new and better ones.
Budgeting Mistake #3: Not Building an Emergency Fund
A major medical problem, a major auto repair, losing your job, etc. Without an emergency fund, it’s not a question of if but when something unexpected like that will happen and knock your finances for a loop. As a result, you may be forced to borrow on your credit cards, with all the impacts and costs of high credit-card debt.
What to do differently:
- Figure out how many months of expenses you should set aside.
- Create an “emergency situation budget” by figuring out what expenses you can’t reduce or avoid altogether.
- Multiply the results of the above two steps – that’s how much you need to set aside for emergencies.
- Prioritize reaching this target relative to other goals and priorities. Once you reach it, you can reallocate those dollars that went into your emergency fund toward the goals you deemphasized until then. Note that once you have enough cash set aside for 2-3 months of expenses in a high-interest checking account, you can consider putting the remainder of your emergency fund into a Roth IRA that’s been open for at least 5 years. You can withdraw your contributions tax- and penalty-free anytime (though you can’t put the money back in, you can just make new contributions per IRS limits). Withdrawing earnings tax- and penalty-free requires that you be over 59.5 years old and that the account was open for 5 tax years (counting from Jan 1 of the year in which you made the first contribution into it).
Budgeting Mistake #4: Not Investing Enough for Retirement
Unless you die before it happens, you will reach a point where you’re unable and/or unwilling to keep working for the money you need to survive. To avoid financial ruin when that happens, you must set aside money for that future self. Further, you must invest this money so the returns, compounded over years and decades, greatly reduce how much you need to contribute to your retirement accounts. If you don’t invest a large enough fraction of your income early enough and long enough, you will spend your retirement in poverty.
What to do differently:
- Develop a retirement budget. If you have no idea how much that should be, one way to estimate it is to start with your adjusted gross income (AGI) as reported to the IRS and subtract it from the amounts you set aside for the future.
- Figure out how much you’ll have coming in from Social Security or other sources. Your best bet here is to go to the Social Security Administration (SSA) website and get their estimate. If you’re married, don’t forget to add your spouse’s retirement or spousal benefits, whichever is higher. Then, reduce those benefits by 23% to account for the looming exhaustion of the Social Security Trust.
- Estimate how much you need to amass to cover the difference between your retirement budget and your expected Social Security benefits. A good way to do this is to multiply the annual calculated shortfall by 33.3. The 4% rule would have you multiply by 25, but recent research indicates that a 3% rule is more appropriate given projected stock market returns.
- Figure out how much you need to invest monthly to reach that portfolio.
Budgeting Mistake #5: Being So Frugal Your Budget Becomes Unsustainable
If you have zero fun now, it’s almost guaranteed that you’ll grow tired of it and fall off the wagon. This is the same problem as going on a too-extreme diet.
What to do differently:
- Find free or inexpensive things you enjoy doing. This could include:
- Potluck dinners with friends, rotating between homes.
- Reading books, either from the library (free) or Kindle Unlimited, which lets you read as many Kindle books as you want for $9.99/month. Alternatively, if you read 2-3 books or less on average each month, you can simply buy the ebooks typically for somewhere between $0.99 and $4.99. This last lets you keep all those titles in your Kindle library.
- Visiting free museums (e.g., Smithsonian museums in DC are free to the public).
- Hiking or running.
- Drawing, writing, or doing any of a host of low-cost crafts.
- Budget at least some money for things you love doing, saving up for them for a year or more if needed. For example, if you set aside $50/month, in a year, you’d have $600 for, e.g., a long weekend at a bed and breakfast close enough to drive to.
- As you reach financial goals, rather than diverting all the money that went toward that goal to the next goal, consider rewarding your present self by diverting some of that money to do fun stuff.
Budgeting Mistake #6: Spending Money You Don’t Have on Things You Don’t Need
The three-word phrase that will doom your finances – “I deserve it.” If something doesn’t align with your goals and priorities and costs a lot, either as a one-time expense or over time, you have to say “no” to it. This is especially true if you can’t afford to pay cash. Credit card debt has huge costs that you really want to avoid.
What to do differently:
- Understand that your true needs are relatively few, while your wants will inevitably grow to and beyond whatever money you have or can borrow.
- For any large expense or budget category, ask yourself what would happen if you had to cut that category’s budget in half or completely do away with it.
- Ask yourself if, given how spending on something that you did last year made you happy to the extent that you’d want to spend the same or more on it this year. The answer will likely be no, in which case, remove it from your budget altogether or at least reduce it significantly.
- If something isn’t in your budget, only add it if you can reduce spending in other categories. For example, say your friends invite you to join them on a cruise. Figure out the total cost and decide if it’s enough of a priority to reduce spending elsewhere by that much. If it isn’t, politely decline.
Budgeting Mistake #7: Buying on Impulse and Not Comparing Prices
Especially with big-ticket items or recurring purchases that add up, failing to compare features and prices guarantees you’ll overspend. This will bust your budget and delay or even prevent achieving your long-term goals. The same is true if you impulse-shop. That’s why businesses spend so much on figuring out what to display, where, how, and in what packaging. It’s to help them separate you from your hard-earned cash in the quickest, most efficient manner.
What to do differently:
- Don’t go shopping unless there’s something specific you need from the particular store.
- Don’t go into a store without a list of things you decided to buy there. Once you have that list, commit to yourself to only buy things from that list. If you see something else you want, write down what it is and how much it costs, and give yourself at least a week’s cooling-off period before deciding if you still want it enough to go back and buy it.
- Research brands, models, options, features, and prices before deciding what to buy.
- Don’t pay for extended warranties unless independent research shows they’re worth buying on the item you’re thinking of buying. For example, say you’re buying a $500 TV that comes with a 2-year warranty, and you’re offered a 4-year extended warranty for another $125. That $125 only covers years 3-4 (since years 1-2 are already covered). Ask yourself (or better yet research) how likely it is that the TV will break within that 2-year extended period. If you think the likelihood is under 25% (since $125 is 25% of $500), skip the extended warranty.
The Bottom Line: Budget for Your Goals, Not Just Your Bills
The above lists my top 7 ways your budgeting fails at getting you to your goals. It also shows what you can do differently to win the budgeting game so you reach your financial goals. This works for both short-term goals, like going on a vacation, and long-term ones, like financial independence.
Budgeting Pro Tip:
Jen Swindler, CFP®, AFC®, Senior Wealth Manager at Vincere Wealth Management, says:
One of the biggest mistakes I see many clients make is failing to plan for ‘revolving’ expenses – known but irregular expenses such as Christmas gifts, birthdays, vacations, vet checkups, annual fees (such as Amazon Prime, Costco, annual insurance premiums, vehicle registration, credit card annual fees, tax-prep fees, etc.
When several of these revolving expenses hit in the same month, they can derail your progress, trigger credit card debt, require withdrawals from emergency funds, etc. To address this, I advise clients to add up their annual expenses, take the monthly average, and add that amount to their savings account each month (or keep it as a checking buffer, though that’s usually less successful). The following table gives an example of how you might do this.
“I’ve found this strategy helps clients plan and avoid having high-expense months throw off their progress. It also helps automated savings amounts to stay stable throughout the year, smoothing out these financial bumps.”
Have you noticed other budgeting pitfalls? Have you come up with ways to avoid them?
Find a Financial Advisor
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most common budgeting mistakes?
Opher Ganel’s top seven are not budgeting at all, not tracking expenses, not saving for emergencies, not investing for the future, being so frugal that the budget becomes unsustainable, spending money you don’t have on things you don’t need, and buying impulsively without comparing prices and features. Each one either leaves you without a plan or lets money leak away from your goals.
How do you figure out how much to keep in an emergency fund?
Decide how many months of expenses you want covered, then build an “emergency situation budget” of only the expenses you can’t reduce or avoid, and multiply the two. The article suggests keeping 2-3 months of expenses in cash and, once that’s in place, considering a Roth IRA that’s been open at least 5 years for the remainder, since contributions can be withdrawn tax- and penalty-free anytime.
How do you budget for irregular expenses like gifts, vacations and annual fees?
One advisor interviewed recommends adding up all your known but irregular “revolving” expenses for the year, taking the monthly average, and moving that amount into savings each month. This keeps months where several of these expenses hit at once from derailing your progress or pushing you into credit card debt.
How much do you need to save for retirement based on your budget?
The article suggests estimating a retirement budget, subtracting expected Social Security benefits (reduced by 23% to allow for the trust fund shortfall), and multiplying the annual gap by 33.3. That reflects a 3% withdrawal rate, which Opher says recent research supports over the 4% rule’s multiplier of 25.
How can you stop impulse buying?
Only go shopping when you need something specific, bring a list and buy only what’s on it, and give yourself at least a week’s cooling-off period before buying anything else you want. Research brands, features and prices first, and skip extended warranties unless the chance of a failure during the extra coverage period exceeds the warranty’s cost as a share of the price.
Find financial advisors who specialize in helping people like you
Search Wealthtender by specialty, location and fee type, compare advisors’ approaches, and read what their clients say before you reach out.
Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only, and should not be considered financial advice. You should consult a financial professional before making any major financial decisions.
About the author
Contributing Writer, Wealthtender
My career has taken some unexpected turns, from earning a PhD in experimental high-energy physics, to conducting cosmic-ray research in Antarctica, to supporting NASA projects and programs, to running my own consulting business. I also run several other small businesses and help my wife run her Marriage and Family Therapy practice.
Those experiences taught me to question assumptions, think critically, and recognize that real-world decisions of any significance rarely have simple answers that apply to everyone. Today, I bring that perspective to writing about personal finance. Drawing on my analytical background, business experience, and research, I explore financial decisions, challenge conventional wisdom, and help readers understand the tradeoffs that can affect their financial well-being. To complement my own research and experience, I also weave insights from financial professionals into my articles, drawing on their expertise and real-world experience helping clients navigate financial decisions and challenges.
At medium.com/@opher-ganel, you can read more of my articles and subscribe to receive email notifications when new ones come out.