Should You Buy Bitcoin in Your 401(k) Plan? These Experts Have Mixed Opinions

By  Brian Thorp

Disclaimer: To make Wealthtender free for our readers, we earn money from advertisers, including financial professionals and firms that pay to be featured. This creates a natural conflict of interest when we favor their promotion over others. Wealthtender is not a client of these financial services providers. Learn how we operate with integrity to earn your trust.

An estimated 16% of Americans have owned cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, primarily in online brokerage accounts and apps, according to a 2021 Pew Research Center survey. But until recently, cryptocurrencies have not been available to employees through retirement plans offered by their employers, limiting their adoption.

Fidelity Investments announced an offering in April 2022 that will make Bitcoin available to millions of employees through their 401(k) plan as early as this summer. In its groundbreaking announcement, Fidelity explained their new Digital Asset Account (DAA) would enable individuals to save a portion of their retirement savings in Bitcoin alongside traditional investments like mutual funds and ETFs.

With the availability of Bitcoin in 401(k) plans, millions of Americans who haven’t yet invested in cryptocurrencies could soon make the leap.

“As a leader in digital assets, we are thrilled to be the first to offer employers exposure to bitcoin for the core lineup of 401(k)s that reflects our commitment to meeting their evolving needs and our belief in the promise of blockchain technology for the financial industry’s future,” said Dave Gray, Head of Workplace Retirement Offerings and Platforms at Fidelity Investments. 

Fidelity will first launch its new DAA account for employees of MicroStrategy, a software company known for its interest and investment in Bitcoin and digital assets. Then, Fidelity plans to make Bitcoin widely available to the thousands of employers on its platform.

Financial Professionals Disagree on the Merits of Bitcoin in 401(k) Plans

We asked financial advisors and investment managers in the Wealthtender community for their thoughts and how they plan to speak with their clients who ask about investing in Bitcoin through their 401(k) plan. We heard mixed opinions, with several professionals excited about the announcement while others expressed doubts and concerns.

“I don’t think that we should evaluate the addition of Bitcoin into 401(k) accounts by Fidelity as a smart or not smart decision,” says Danielle Miura, founder of Spark Financials. “Even though Fidelity might be making this decision to please its customers, they will likely have to add disclosures to protect themselves from customer accusations,” Miura says.

Beyond the additional disclosures, Miura fears account holders may bear the burden of increased account fees resulting from the risk of additional liabilities. The question of increased costs also arose among advisors wondering how much Fidelity will charge individuals who choose to invest in Bitcoin.

“A case could be made for some clients that holding Bitcoin in their 401(k) for further diversification would be beneficial,” says Tyler Hackenberg, founder of Drexel Day Financial. “But a huge question mark with the announcement is how much it would cost to hold in a 401(k),” says Hackenberg.

Beyond the cost of investing in Bitcoin, financial advisors found reassurance in Fidelity’s stance to limit how much an individual can invest in the cryptocurrency through their 401(k) plan.

“We believe Fidelity is being prudent by trying to mitigate the risk to investors by implementing a 20% account balance cap to Bitcoin,” say Alexis and Tim Woodward, co-founders of Blend Wealth. As cryptocurrency specialists who have earned the Certified Digital Asset Advisor designation, the couple also added, “Overall, it’s great that investors can finally access this asset class in a simplified way, and we like that there’s some protection in place so that a new investor doesn’t overweight their portfolio in one concentrated position.” 

Ryan Firth, founder of Mercer Street Financial, echos this sentiment, saying, “I think holding Bitcoin for the long-term in a retirement account could make sense, as long as the allocation is kept at or below 5% of the investor’s total assets.”

Another consideration raised by financial advisors is the topic of fiduciary responsibility for 401(k) plans. The Department of Labor maintains oversight for the employer-sponsored retirement plan space and holds employers who sponsor 401(k) plans for their employees accountable for fiduciary liability, not the retirement plan recordkeeper.

“It’s important to note that recordkeepers, like Fidelity, do not carry fiduciary responsibility,” says Richard Archer, President of Archer Investment Management.  “It’s down to each plan sponsor, as fiduciary, to vet the digital asset offering and determine if it’s appropriate to add these options to the plan’s core lineup, with the guidance of financial advisors as prudent experts.  Each plan fiduciary will need to evaluate their workforce demographics and education level before determining if this option is prudent for their workforce makeup,” Archer says.

The Typical Investor Behavior in 401(k) Plans Could Bode Well for Bitcoin as an Investment Option

Some advisors noted the typical investing behavior of employees in their 401(k) plans could prove favorable for Bitcoin as a newly available investment option.

“We believe that crypto is here to stay,” says Alan Rhode, founder and CEO of Modern Wealth. “We tend to see less trading by clients in their 401(k) than that of their self-directed investment accounts, so the bias of buying high and selling low could be avoided, which is a huge plus,” says Rhode.

Whether or not investors have the fortitude to handle the extreme volatility of Bitcoin within their 401(k) plan is a concern expressed by several financial advisors.

“Including Bitcoin in 401(k) plans is a great way to provide exposure to cryptocurrency for individuals who are interested in investing in it,” says Blaine Thiederman, founder of Progress Wealth Management. “The issue is, behaviorally, bitcoin isn’t for the meek of heart, and most investors lack discipline. Bitcoin is more volatile, more unpredictable, and less reliable than the stock market is. The fact of the matter is that most investors have a hard time staying disciplined with an ETF portfolio, let alone cryptocurrency. This is why investing in cryptocurrency isn’t for everyone,” Thiederman says.

Several Financial Professionals Have Concerns About Bitcoin in 401(k) Plans

Additional concerns raised by financial advisors include the loss of tax benefits that may be available in an account outside of a 401(k) plan.

“For many investors, it may make sense to hold Bitcoin and other digital assets in a non-qualified account due to the favorable tax treatment (under current law) that allows for significant tax-loss harvesting due to the inherent volatility of these assets,” says Ian Weiner, founder of Simply Retire. “Many investors interested in digital assets and Bitcoin take a ‘never sell’ approach to owning these assets and view loans against these assets as a way to access them – this would seem to be severely limited inside a 401(k),” says Weiner.

David Creekmore, the founder of Lifetime Financial, is skeptical of Bitcoin as an investment and doubts many employers will permit their employees to invest in Bitcoin, even once Fidelity makes the cryptocurrency available as an investment option.

“I’m not a fan of crypto in retirement portfolios. We don’t know how it behaves as an asset class, volatility, correlations, and the distribution of expected returns. A small amount (5%) is fine if it helps the client stay the course,” says Creekmore. “The real hurdles are the federal standards that apply to 401(k) plans and the companies that offer them. The fiduciary obligations are higher than most investment offerings and most, I think, won’t offer crypto soon or ever,” says Creekmore.

Darryl Lyons, CEO of Pax Financial Group, shares this concern, stating, “Even though the consumer has an interest, it is the employer who will decide if cryptocurrency will be on the menu of company 401(k) plans. With the level of 401(k) litigation in recent years, I have a hard time seeing employers adopting Bitcoin as an investment selection.”

Guy Davis, Managing Director and Portfolio Manager at GCI Investors, adds a healthy dose of skepticism to the mixed bag of expert opinions. Davis says Bitcoin should be considered speculative and not an investment, creating risks for the employers who make the cryptocurrency available to their employees.

“Bitcoin being allowed in 401(k) plans and investment portfolios is a marketing tool that will attract naïve and vulnerable investors- and could easily be seen as a lack of fiduciary care for clients,” says Davis. “Just because a child wants to play with scissors doesn’t mean you should let them.”

Deciding Whether or Not You Will Buy Bitcoin in Your 401(k)

Before transferring a portion of your retirement savings into Bitcoin, you should first consult a financial professional knowledgeable in crypto who can offer personalized guidance based on your unique circumstances and risk tolerance. You might also consider hiring a financial advisor who has earned specialist credentials to demonstrate their knowledge of cryptocurrencies, such as the Certificate in Blockchain and Digital Assets, and the Certified Digital Asset Advisor designation.

And as always, when investing in a speculative asset like Bitcoin, you should never invest more than you can afford to lose.

Disclaimer: This article is intended for informational purposes only, and should not be considered financial advice. You should consult a financial professional before making any major financial decisions.

Find Your Next Financial Advisor on Wealthtender

📍 Click on a pin in the map view below for a preview of financial advisors who can help you reach your money goals with a personalized plan. Or choose the grid view to search our directory of financial advisors with additional filtering options.

Ron Zunker Pax Financial Group Fee Based Fiduciary Advisor
Serving Clients Nationwide
San Antonio, Texas
Mark V Powell Edward Jones Financial Advisor
Serving Clients Nationwide
Huntsville, Alabama
Laura Simpson, CFP® PAX Financial Group Fee Based Fiduciary Advisor
Serving Clients Nationwide
San Antonio, Texas
Guy Davis, CFA GCI Investors We invest, we don’t speculate.
Serving Clients Nationwide
Houston, Texas
Michael Jensen, CFP® Falcon Wealth Planning Planning Made Simple.
Serving Clients Nationwide
Irvine, California
Adell, Harriman & Carpenter, Inc. Your financial home for every season of life.
Houston, Texas
Charles F. Hall Jr. Clear Rock Advisors Managing Wealth for Generations
Serving Clients Nationwide
Austin, Texas
Ty Sanders Clear Rock Advisors Managing Wealth for Generations
Serving Clients Nationwide
Austin, Texas
Corey Long, CFP® Clear Rock Advisors Managing Wealth for Generations
Serving Clients Nationwide
Austin, Texas
Corey Noyes, AAMS Balanced Capital Align Your Portfolio With The Kind Of World You Want To Create
Heber City, Utah
David T. DeWitt, CFP®, CSRIC DeWitt Capital Management Financial Planning for the Next Generation
Wayne, Pennsylvania
David DeWitt DeWitt Capital Management Podcaster 🎙️, financial planner💸, and ADHDer. 🦋
Wayne, Pennsylvania
Bob Gavlak, CFP® WealthSource Sophisticated Expertise. Approachable Advice.
Columbus, Ohio
The Goff Financial Group Fee-Only | Fully Independent | Fiduciary
Serving Clients Nationwide
Houston, Texas

📍Double-click or pinch pins to view more.

About the Author
A headshot of Brian Thorp, the founder and CEO of Wealthtender

About the Author

Brian Thorp

Brian is CEO and founder of Wealthtender. He and his wife live in Texas, enjoying the diversity of Houston and the vibrancy of Austin.

With over 25 years in the financial services industry, Brian is applying his experience and passion at Wealthtender to help more people enjoy life with less money stress.

Connect with Brian on LinkedIn

Disclaimer: To make Wealthtender free for our readers, we earn money from advertisers, including financial professionals and firms that pay to be featured. This creates a natural conflict of interest when we favor their promotion over others. Wealthtender is not a client of these financial services providers. Learn how we operate with integrity to earn your trust.